What Reddit recommends for Supplements.

For health-conscious buyers with a drawer of half-finished bottles who no longer trust a label. See which products people name most and open the comments behind the ranking.

12 products147 comments4 threadsupdated 5 hours ago
  1. Zinc

    mixed
    8

    Recommended for testosterone support. Users note more than 18mg can reduce copper absorption, should be taken with copper.

    Being around women, weight lifting, and engaging in earnest competition Otherwise, vitamin D, zinc, and good sleep

    01
  2. Creatine

    love
    7

    Most recommended supplement with decades of research. Users notice improved athletic performance, strength, and recovery from gym workouts.

    $44.00 $0.49/ct · 4.7★ (5,400) · Thorne

    Creatine and then whatever you are currently deficient in. Most people don’t eat fish so need omega 3, don’t get sun then get d3 with k2. Don’t eat enough nuts then get magnesium? I think this correct enough

    02
  3. Magnesium

    love
    7

    Recommended for those who don't eat enough nuts. Part of the core supplement stack many users suggest.

    $4.79 $0.08/ct · 3.2★ (61) · Target

    Creatine and then whatever you are currently deficient in. Most people don’t eat fish so need omega 3, don’t get sun then get d3 with k2. Don’t eat enough nuts then get magnesium? I think this correct enough

    03
  4. Tongkat Ali

    mixed
    7

    Some studies show testosterone increase, others show no difference. May help if testosterone is low but limited effect on healthy levels.

    Some studies show tongkat ali raises testosterone 100 points. Some studies show no difference. Only thing that ever gave me any libido at all is lifting weights for about 45 minutes, including compound exercises. More than 18 miligrams of zinc, food and supplements combined…

    04
  5. Boron

    love
    5

    Users report it increases free testosterone. 6mg dose mentioned as effective.

    Tongkat Ali, Boron and to a lesser degree Ashwagandha. Fadogia Aggrestis once it passes human trials.

    05
  6. K2

    love
    4

    Commonly paired with Vitamin D3 for optimal absorption and effectiveness.

    Creatine and then whatever you are currently deficient in. Most people don’t eat fish so need omega 3, don’t get sun then get d3 with k2. Don’t eat enough nuts then get magnesium? I think this correct enough

    06
  7. Ashwagandha

    mixed
    4

    Mentioned as having some testosterone benefits but to a lesser degree than other options.

    Like the other comment, I also experimented with Ashwagandha, Tongkat Ali, Fadogia Agrestis, Maca, Horny Goat Weed, Tribulus and more when I was younger. Something, like Shilajit resin is more sustainable, but the effects are typically not as profound and noticeable, and heavy…

    07
  8. Vitamin D3

    love
    1

    Recommended especially for those who don't get sun exposure. Often paired with K2 for better absorption.

    $6.39 $0.06/ct · 4.6★ (1,800) · Target

    Creatine and then whatever you are currently deficient in. Most people don’t eat fish so need omega 3, don’t get sun then get d3 with k2. Don’t eat enough nuts then get magnesium? I think this correct enough

    08
  9. Omega 3 / Fish Oil

    love
    1

    Recommended for those who don't eat fish. Some note it may affect blood clotting. Algae-derived options available.

    $24.99 $0.83/ct · 4.7★ (348) · GNC

    Creatine and then whatever you are currently deficient in. Most people don’t eat fish so need omega 3, don’t get sun then get d3 with k2. Don’t eat enough nuts then get magnesium? I think this correct enough

    09
  10. Fiber supplements

    love
    1

    Lower cholesterol and blood sugar, improve bowel movements, make you feel good, and are quite cheap.

    Fiber supplements, 100%. Lower cholesterol, lower blood sugar, make you feel good, great bowel movements, and they are quite cheap

    10
  11. NAC

    love
    1

    Gets honorable mention as a worthwhile supplement to consider.

    NAC should get honorable mention

    11
  12. Testosterone Cypionate

    mixed
    1

    User reports it works well but others warn it can cause infertility and shut down natural testosterone production.

    Testosterone Cypionate has worked pretty well for me.

    12

Want every comment behind this list, plus the ad angles in them?

Scrape it in Adlicio
01How it works

How to use Product Finder

  1. 01

    Review the category

    Use the prefilled product category or replace it with another one.

  2. 02

    Find products

    Press Find products to search useful Reddit threads and count named recommendations.

  3. 03

    Open the receipts

    Compare the ranked products and read the linked comments behind each result.

02Buyer language

What these buyers say

I have a whole drawer of half-finished bottles I never felt anything from
I take like 12 pills a day and honestly cannot tell if a single one does anything
Every brand says third-party tested but who is actually testing them
03FAQ

Product finder FAQ

How does Product Finder rank products?

It searches Reddit for threads about the category, reads the most useful comments, identifies named products, then counts how many collected comments mention each one. The list is sorted by that count.

Is Product Finder free?

Yes. You can run free searches without an account. Repeated searches are cached, so popular categories often return immediately without using another public run.

Why use Reddit for product recommendations?

Reddit threads contain detailed comparisons from people who have tried several options. The useful part is not a single opinion. It is the repeated product names and reasons that appear across many comments.

What does mentions mean?

Mentions is the number of comments in this search that name the product. It is counted from the collected comments in code after extraction, not estimated by the language model.

How do I get every comment behind the ranking?

Open the linked receipts to inspect individual comments. To collect the full conversation and turn it into ad angles, scrape the source threads in Adlicio.
04More free tools

Other free tools

05All free tools

All free tools on Adlicio